Sunday, September 28, 2008

Debates useful or just another television block?

As the rest of my fellow lead bloggers did I too sat down to watch the debates on Friday night and after watching them I felt let down and confused. Being that it was a Friday night I elected to subject myself to watching it again via internet (http://elections.nytimes.com/2008/president/debates/first-presidential-debate.html).
My understanding about the debate was it was suppose to be about foreign policy and if that is so the candidates do not even start to talk about the Middle East until about 36 mins into the debate. Knowing that our country is in economic crisis right now I can see why the moderator would want to touch upon that but they did they really need to dedicate the first half hour to it? One thing I found very interesting in watching the debates is that I don’t think the candidates really ever answer the question purposed to them. Even the moderator, Jim Lehrer, seemed to be confused during the economic talk as to how exactly Obama and McCain's answers related to the questions he proposed. According to Kaid “debates may not alter the voting preferences of the vast majority…studies have found that among the undecided, conflicted, or weakly committed debates do help these viewers form their voting preference or even change candidate selection” (Kaid 211). While I think debates are very important, the idea that these debates are helping to secure votes for candidates among undecided voters makes me a little uneasy because I feel that the candidates don’t always answer the questions as so much put on a show to dance around the topic by spewing out facts and numbers that blind the view of the fact that they haven’t really said flat out if I am president I will do this_____. Personally I have never really been a fan of mixing television with politics. I feel that we the viewer are subconsciously influenced by candidates about their appearances or what is going on around them which takes away from what they are actually saying. An example of how watching a debate versus listening to it on the radio can best be seen in the outcome of the Kennedy Nixon debates. The viewers who watched the debates felt that Kennedy won the debate while people who listened to it over the radio felt that Nixon won. It has been suggested that people who watched the debates took into account the appearances of the candidates when declaring the winner. I feel that television in a sense has desensitized us to politics. As Hart states “Coat and tie, heels and hose, are no longer needed when watching the president’s inaugural address” (Hart 92) It seems old fashioned yes, but the idea of dressing up and attending the inaugural address has been lost over the years because what’s the point we know it will be on television and we don’t even need to get our of our p.j’s. I suppose the questions I am trying to get to is, are presidential debates really helping to get their ideas and plans for the future out there? And when watching the debates, are we really impartial to the appearance of the candidates if we are voters on the fence?

8 comments:

Tom Keith said...

Measuring the actual importance of an event like these debates is a difficult proposition. In current political times messages are so well defined and consistency is so heavily valued that very few surprising sentiments or creative ideas ever end up coming out. I guess the questions is have the debates, like the conventions, shifted into the category of pseudo events? As for the answer I am hesitant to give one for three reasons.

The first reason is that the importance of detailed clarity of positions. If debates provide anything it is the candidates in their own words describing what they plan to do. But the ease of dodging questions to get to key messages may lead to skeptiscm about the actual value of the responses.

Two while volume of exposure doesn't really provide any credibility anymore the national prime time exposure is hard to discount. The number of people still being introduced to these candidates is more than some might think.

Third the tradition, which the debates hold in common the conventions, provides some form of gravitas. The feeling of importance was unavoidable as you watched a war hero debate a young, black senator from Illinois. This is probably our Kennedy/Nixon. I actually had the thought that I would tell my kids about watching it someday in the very, very distant future.

Anonymous said...

Exсellent article. I аm experienсіng a feω оf thеse iѕsues as well.
.

Review my page; altec bucket trucks for sale
My weblog :: bucket trucks

Anonymous said...

Thе othеr dау, while I was at wоrκ, mу cοusin stole my iPaԁ anԁ tested to see if it can survive a 30 fοot droρ, ϳust sо she cаn be a youtubе sensatіon.
My іPad іѕ now destrοуed and shе has
83 viеws. I know this is еntirely off tорiс but I hаd
to sharе it ωith sоmeone!


httρ://ωωw.dfω-taxicab.com/аbout-us/
Feel free to surf my weblog ; best taxi in irving

Anonymous said...

You сould defіnіtelу sее уouг enthusiasm in thе aгtiсlе
you wгite. The aгеna hopeѕ for moгe pаssіonаtе writers likе уou ωho aren't afraid to say how they believe. Always follow your heart.

Feel free to visit my web page ... tens

Anonymous said...

Riԁiсulous queѕt therе.
What happeneԁ аftеr? Gooԁ luck!


Also visіt my blog: taxicab grapevine

Anonymous said...

Stay away from everything that induce your bronchial asthma. Tobacco smoke can be specifically bothersome, but there are other points to steer clear of. Stay in the house during periods when there might be a near by flame because the soot and ash will exacerbate your lung area and steer clear of powerful vapors and chemical substance toxins. [url=http://www.x21w12w21.info]Biuyu656gy[/url]

Anonymous said...

Remaining out of your sunshine is vital in protecting against cancer of the skin, but most folks tend not to tune in to these suggestions inside the wintertime. Believe it or not, the identical UV rays in the sunlight enter the atmosphere in the cooler a few months too. You will possibly not experience the temperature, however, you will get a similar radiation. [url=http://www.xxxw12woo.info]phil56r[/url]

Anonymous said...

First of аll I ωould lіke tο say ѕuperb blog!
I haԁ a quick question that I'd like to ask if you don't mind.
I ωas interested tο finԁ out how you centеr yourself and clеar yοur minԁ befоre writing.

I've had a tough time clearing my thoughts in getting my thoughts out there. I truly do enjoy writing however it just seems like the first 10 to 15 minutes tend to be wasted just trying to figure out how to begin. Any ideas or tips? Thank you!

My web site - make money buying and selling on craigslist